"Do not pay the ransom!," urged the now‑defunct RansomwareHelp website as it promised "100% data recovery, all backed by a success rate of over 99%." Those claims are central to an indictment returned this week in Rhode Island that accuses the company's chief technology officer and co‑founder of a different reality: secretly paying extortionists for decryptors and billing victims far above the amounts allegedly paid.
Indictment charges Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar with wire fraud
The indictment names 52‑year‑old Juan Ricardo Palacio Escobar of Miami and Medellín, Colombia, as the co‑founder and chief technology officer of ransomwarehelp.com and charges him with wire fraud. According to the charging document, the company — which for six years touted "advanced cryptographic tools" and said it would "never promote, intermediate or pay ransom to threat actors on behalf of our clients" — routinely paid ransomware groups for decryption keys while representing to clients that it would not make such payments.
FBI sting: fake victim and a fictitious ransomware group
The government alleges an FBI sting that posed simultaneously as a ransomware victim company and as a fictitious ransomware group. Posing as a victim, investigators supplied RansomwareHelp a phony ransomware note and said they did not want to pay. RansomwareHelp reiterated its public policy against paying attackers, the indictment says. Federal agents posing as the ransomware group, however, allege that Palacio contacted them to request the lowest possible price for a decryptor.
According to the indictment, FBI agents offered a price of 0.2 bitcoin — roughly $13,000 at the time — and within 48 hours Palacio told the agents acting as the victim that a diagnostic assessment had succeeded and that the decrypting cost would be $13,260. The government further alleges Palacio later sought to reduce the ransom to $4,000 and ultimately agreed on approximately $6,000 in bitcoin with the fake ransomware group, while charging the fake victim $16,010 (including a $2,750 diagnostic fee and the $13,260 fee).

Nobody's watching your logs at 2 AM.
Full SOC coverage without building one. Nubivance deploys and manages Rapid7 InsightIDR and MDR for organizations that need detection and response, not another dashboard.
Get coverageSoteria co‑founder Paul Ihme and a real victim's experience
Paul Ihme, co‑founder of the security firm Soteria, recounted to KrebsOnSecurity that in 2024 a small accounting firm had paid RansomwareHelp a diagnostic fee after a LockBit infection. Ihme said the company received a proposal from RansomwareHelp quoting $438,880 for recovery work that listed items such as "professional configuration of forensic servers," "expert engineering hours of programming to configure decryption algorithms," and "eight (6‑hour processing cycles) related to the decryption process."
The proposal also claimed the recovery would use "510 preconfigured forensic servers of the maximum quantitative capacity located in different parts of the world" and asserted RansomwareHelp would "inject randomly the encryption codes extracted during the forensic and cryptographic analysis using brute force processes." Ihme called those technical assertions "patently farcical" and said he believed RansomwareHelp targeted small‑to‑medium businesses lacking technical advisors.
Remote access, deleted ransom notes, and parallel negotiations with LockBit
Ihme said RansomwareHelp insisted on unrestricted remote access to the victim's network via an AnyDesk installer to run diagnostics. Ihme told KrebsOnSecurity that a forensic review found only one copy of the ransom note — recovered from a backup snapshot — and that when they connected to LockBit's chat server with the provided user ID they discovered someone had been negotiating with LockBit for several days.
Screenshots and chat transcripts obtained by investigators and reported by KrebsOnSecurity show RansomwareHelp negotiating with LockBit and repeatedly asking the extortionists not to reveal those negotiations to the victim. LockBit's representative grew frustrated, warning the victim that delays would increase the ransom by $100,000 per day. Ultimately, the accounting firm followed Ihme's advice, engaged a more established firm, and paid about half of what RansomwareHelp had proposed, Ihme said.
How this case fits with other recent DoJ prosecutions
The Palacio indictment is the latest of several Department of Justice actions that allege security vendors or negotiators conspired with fraudsters or otherwise defrauded clients. The reporting notes an early‑October charging of Edward Dubrovsky, an executive at Canadian cybersecurity firm Cybersteward, whose case is sealed but who faces cyber extortion and conspiracy charges. The DoJ also charged MonsterCloud CEO Zohar Pinhasi with wire fraud and conspiracy, alleging he secretly paid ransomware groups $8 million while charging customers $19 million. In July, Angelo Martino, a ransomware negotiator from Land O’Lakes, Florida, was sentenced to 70 months in prison for conspiring with the BlackCat/ALPHV ransomware group to extort multiple victims, according to the DoJ.
What this means for technologists, small businesses, and regulators
- Technologists and security teams: incident responders and forensic investigators should watch for unusual remote‑access requirements and discrepancies in the presence of ransom notes across systems; in this case, investigators found only a single copy of a note in a backup snapshot and evidence of third‑party negotiation on the attackers' chat server.
- Small and medium‑sized businesses and procurement leaders: the indictment and victim accounts show how firms promising improbable technical capabilities (for example, "100% data recovery" using hundreds of "preconfigured forensic servers") may still be charging outsized prices; one victim was quoted $438,880 and another was billed $16,010 including a $2,750 diagnostic fee for services the government says amounted to buying a decryptor.
- Policymakers and regulators: prosecutors are actively pursuing alleged fraud by remediation providers, and recent cases cited by the DoJ show multiple criminal charges and a sentence in a related matter — signaling enforcement attention to firms that misrepresent their practices to extortion victims.
The indictment in Rhode Island frames a central, practical question for organizations hit by ransomware: when a remediation vendor promises proprietary cryptography and near‑certain recovery, are they doing the work they claim or simply negotiating — and marking up — payments to attackers? The government now alleges the latter in this case; the court process will determine the facts the indictment asserts.
Source: KrebsOnSecurity, "CTO of ‘RansomwareHelp’ Indicted for Wire Fraud"




