Skip to main content
CybersecurityHacking

Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Heist Case

Federal courthouse interior with natural light, empty seats, and a blurred judge's bench.
"The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes. It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the Government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case," U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke wrote in granting a judgment of acquittal for Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno.

Judge Jessica Clarke’s acquittal: legal standard and finding

Judge Clarke concluded the government failed to meet the legal threshold needed to sustain wire fraud and related convictions. Citing the familiar prosecutorial standard — whether evidence, when viewed in the light most favorable to the government, could support the charges — Clarke found prosecutors did not prove that the brothers made any material misrepresentations in executing their alleged scheme. The judge therefore granted the defense motion and entered judgments of acquittal for both Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno.

What prosecutors alleged about the $25 million Ethereum theft

Prosecutors described a sophisticated, multi-stage plot that culminated in the theft of approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency in “about 12 seconds.” According to the indictment and the government's case at trial, the alleged scheme included these elements:

  • Accessing pending private transactions and altering them to obtain victims’ cryptocurrency.
  • Deploying “bait transactions” to identify “victim traders.”
  • Exploiting a vulnerability in MEV-Boost relay code that caused a relay to prematurely release the full content of a proposed block and then reordering that proposed block to the defendants’ advantage.
  • Rejecting requests to return stolen funds, moving the assets through a series of transactions, using multiple cryptocurrency addresses and foreign exchanges, and setting up shell companies to obscure source and ownership.

Prosecutors also alleged the brothers searched online for information on carrying out the attack, concealing their involvement, and laundering proceeds via exchanges with lax verification, and that they hired attorneys with expertise in cryptocurrency and extradition procedures while preparing and executing the plan.

MEV-Boost relay vulnerability and block reordering: the technical claim

The government’s technical theory centered on an exploit of the MEV-Boost relay code. Prosecutors said the defendants caused a relay to release the full content of a proposed block prematurely, then reordered that proposed block to favor their own transactions — actions that, per the indictment, directly led to the roughly $25 million loss for victim traders on the Ethereum blockchain. Those procedural and timing maneuvers were presented at trial as the mechanism that enabled rapid transfer of funds within seconds.

Timeline and criminal process: December 2022 planning to 2026 acquittal

Prosecutors said preparation for the attack began in December 2022. The two brothers were arrested in May 2024 in Boston and New York on wire fraud and money laundering charges; each count carried a statutory exposure of up to 20 years in prison if convicted. The 2026 judgment of acquittal follows a mistrial in the same case roughly one year earlier, when jurors failed to agree on verdicts in the first trial of these allegations.

How technologists, policymakers, and exchanges are implicated

  • Technologists and security teams: The prosecution’s focus on MEV-Boost relay behavior and block reordering highlights attack vectors native to blockchain transaction ordering and relay code — areas that developers and node operators will likely examine to assess protocol-level vulnerabilities and relay implementations.
  • Policymakers and regulators: The case illustrates the difficulties of proving traditional fraud elements — such as material misrepresentation — in crimes that hinge on software behavior and blockchain mechanics, a nuance that could influence how regulations and enforcement strategies are drafted or prioritized.
  • Cryptocurrency exchanges and compliance teams: Prosecutors’ allegations that stolen funds were routed through multiple addresses, foreign exchanges, and entities with lax verification underline persistent compliance challenges around transaction provenance and counterparty due diligence.

The court’s ruling closes this prosecution while leaving intact the record of a detailed allegation about a rapid, code-driven theft on Ethereum. It also leaves open the question Judge Clarke framed at the outset: whether the available evidence could meet the legal elements of wire fraud when the disputed conduct is rooted in the technical behavior of blockchain software. For developers, regulators, and market operators, the case will be read not just for its outcome but for the operational and evidentiary contours it exposed.

Original story