Marsh’s Global Insurance Market Index shows global cyber rates falling for a 13th consecutive quarter, a cooling that masks a tougher underwriting playbook: carriers are now demanding proof that insured organizations can actually recover from an attack, not just that backups exist.
Marsh’s index and the market reaction
Insurers have relaxed pricing after the ransomware-driven spikes of 2020 and 2021, with US rates recently stabilizing. That easing has come with a price: carriers are tightening the terms they will accept. According to brokers cited in the report, a major global carrier recently stopped writing law firms entirely because of claims volume, and brokers expect healthcare and managed service providers (MSPs) to be next. Underwriters are moving beyond checklists to require demonstrable, tested recovery capability.
Beltex webinar: the new underwriting checklist
In a webinar with cyber insurance provider Beltex, insurers’ familiar technical demands appeared alongside a new, operational bar. Requirements called out in the session include multifactor authentication (MFA) on external access and privileged accounts, endpoint detection and response (EDR) on every endpoint, a staffed 24/7 team where managed detection and response (MDR) is required, and timely patching. Backup has now joined that list — but with a twist: some carriers want evidence of a successful restore within the last six months, and some insurance applications must be signed by a C-level executive rather than an IT director to put ownership behind the assertion.

Audit-ready is a season. It shouldn't be.
Evidence in spreadsheets, controls drifting between audits, frameworks multiplying on flat headcount. Nubivance runs continuous compliance on Rapid7 Cyber GRC - SOC 2, HIPAA, ISO 27001, PCI, CMMC.
End the scrambleClaims lessons: the 85-person firm and why speed matters
Claims experience is driving the shift. Beltex recounted an 85-person firm hit through a zero-day firewall flaw: the firm’s MDR solution contained the intrusion in about 20 minutes, forensics confirmed two servers were touched, and clean backups had the firm fully functional within 36 hours. The resulting claim totaled roughly $85,000. By contrast, Beltex compared downtime costs: a firm billing $10,000 a day that is offline for a week loses $70,000 in income before recovery costs and claim submission. Large servers, the report notes, can take four to 24 hours to restore — a window in which business-interruption losses mount and claim costs balloon. Insurers don’t refuse to pay claims; they object to paying very large ones, which is why underwriters now focus as much on recovery speed as on the mere existence of backups.
Where you recover matters: containment, forensics, and cloud DR
Recovery location is the other half of the problem. Breach counsel treats the first 72 hours as the most critical window, and incident response teams need to isolate and investigate infected systems during it. Restoring into production too early risks reintroducing the threat and disturbing evidence investigators need; recovery that is fast but not safe satisfies no one. Cloud-native disaster recovery can address both speed and safety: the report describes Cove’s DRaaS solution, which lets teams stage a pre-recovered VM in the N‑able cloud that can be failed over to in about 15 minutes, off the production network. That approach allows forensic investigators to validate and hunt in the sandbox while the business keeps moving, with rollback to earlier points in time and failback using recovery agents when the recovery point is agreed clean.
What this means for MSPs, healthcare providers, and policyholders
- MSPs: The report specifically flags MSPs as “least ready” for the newer insurer demands; brokers expect MSPs to be a focus for underwriting restrictions next, and Beltex’s examples underline the operational work MSPs must demonstrate — tested restores, documented RTOs/RPOs, and executive sign-off.
- Healthcare providers: Brokers expect the healthcare sector to face increased underwriting scrutiny similar to law firms, meaning proof-of-recovery and demonstrable containment practices will influence insurability and pricing.
- Policyholders and procurement leaders: The note recommends buyers check for a standalone cyber policy rather than a small add-on, with at least $1 million in limits and $2 million as the business scales, and to make practical preparations — list what the business cannot lose for 72 hours, set recovery targets, test them, and document results.
Underwriters want to see reasonable care, not a row of green checkmarks. The practical checklist in the report is straightforward: run a test restore; confirm you’re protecting everything that matters, including the server someone labeled “not in production”; have the business owner confirm systems returned within agreed recovery time objectives (RTO) and recovery point objectives (RPO); and keep logs, screenshots and sign-off in the ticketing system. If incident response is required, the report also advises disconnecting affected machines from the network rather than powering them off, so forensic data survives.
The market signal is clear: cheaper premiums will be conditional on demonstrable operational readiness. For organizations and their insurers, the next move is less paperwork and more rehearsals — test restores, documented timelines and a safe recovery location that lets investigators do their job while the business keeps running.




